Let’s be real for a second—sometimes Christmas cheer needs a bit of a twist. I mean, the jolly tunes, the cozy fireside chats, and the endless supply of gingerbread cookies are great, but there’s something about a little suspense to really spice up the holiday season, right? 🎅🔥
If you’re the kind of person who loves a good thrill—especially one wrapped in a Christmas bow—then Christmas thrillers are about to become your new holiday obsession. These stories bring together all the season’s warmth with the nail-biting tension of a great suspenseful mystery. Snowy landscapes, shadowy figures lurking just beyond the festive lights, and a plot so twisted you’ll be guessing until the very last page. It’s like the best Christmas party, but with a dash of danger and a sprinkle of “what the heck just happened?” 🤔
So, whether you’re into psychological thrillers, classic whodunnits, or Christmas-themed crimes that’ll keep you on the edge of your seat, I’ve got a list of books that’ll make your holiday season as thrilling as it is cozy. Ready to add a little mystery (and a whole lot of suspense) to your holiday reading list? Grab a blanket, a cup of something warm (preferably spiked), and let’s get to the thrill!
10 Christmas Thriller Books That’ll Keep You on the Edge of Your Seat
I’ve rounded up ten thriller books that will get you into the holiday spirit—if your holiday spirit is a bit on the darker side. These books mix festive cheer with heart-pounding suspense, and they’ll keep you guessing from the first page to the last. So, let’s read, shall we? 🔍🎅
1. “The 12 Deaths of Christmas” by Marian Babson
📖 Goodreads Rating: 3.9/5
Genres: Mystery, Cozy Mystery, Holiday, Suspense.
First off, if you’re expecting a jolly, Hallmark-style Christmas story, this book will definitely surprise you. In The 12 Deaths of Christmas, the story takes place in a small English town during the holiday season, and it’s a classic cozy mystery with a twist. It’s told from the perspective of several characters, with the central theme being that an unusual (and slightly dark) death happens on each of the twelve days leading up to Christmas.
From the outset, we’re introduced to a motley crew of characters—everyone from a grumpy detective to a mysterious old woman, a quirky couple, and a series of other townsfolk who seem like they might be harboring more secrets than you’d expect for a holiday tale. As Christmas approaches, one by one, characters drop dead in a way that seems eerily timed to the twelve days of Christmas. (The title should have given you a clue, right?)
🔪 Why It’s a Chilling:
What makes this book so fun is that it’s equal parts comedic and chilling, with a good dose of holiday irreverence. There’s a strong sense of mystery, but it doesn’t take itself too seriously. It’s almost like a dark parody of Christmas—just the right amount of fun and sinister for the right kind of reader. 🕵️♂️
🎄 Personal Take:
I’m a huge fan of cozy mysteries, and I’m always on the lookout for something unique that adds a little twist to the formula. The 12 Deaths of Christmas was just what I needed—unexpected, darkly funny, and clever enough to keep me intrigued the whole way through.
I’m not saying this book will turn you into a detective (though, if you are one, I think you’d enjoy solving this mystery), but it’s a delightful blend of humor and suspense that really made my holiday reading season feel complete. And, honestly, after reading a dozen mysterious deaths around Christmas time, I’m feeling like I’m ready for some classic feel-good holiday stories… but that’s for another day. 😉
2. “The Christmas Killer” by Alex Pine
📖 Goodreads Rating: 4.02/5
Tropes: Serial killer, holiday horror, police procedural.
When a serial killer begins targeting victims during the holidays, Detective Jane Tennison is forced to race against time to catch the killer before Christmas arrives. As the body count rises, the chilling atmosphere of the season only adds to the intensity.
👀 Why It’s Gripping:
The pacing is tight, and the investigation has all the right elements of a great thriller—tension, urgency, and a dark killer. The holiday season adds a layer of irony, making it all the more unsettling.
💭 Personal Take:
This is the kind of book that makes you want to lock the doors and stay inside. It’s not for the faint of heart, but if you’re looking for a hard-hitting thriller with a holiday backdrop, this is your book.
3. “A Christmas Carol Murders” by Sam McPhee
📖 Goodreads Rating: 3.83/5
Tropes: Classic reimagined, historical mystery, Christmas ghosts.
This book takes Charles Dickens’ classic A Christmas Carol and spins it into a chilling murder mystery. What if Scrooge wasn’t just visited by ghosts of Christmas past, present, and future—but by something much darker? This twisty tale brings murder, suspense, and a mystery behind Scrooge’s past life.
🎩 Why It’s Intriguing:
The classic A Christmas Carol meets detective noir in a fantastic re-imagining. It has all the familiar characters you know and love from Dickens, but with a sinister twist.
🎄 Personal Take:
This was such a fun read! I never thought I’d get a Christmas thriller mixed with one of my all-time favorite stories. The dark twists kept me engaged, and it was fascinating to see a beloved character in such a different light.
4. “The Christmas Secret” by Wanda E. Brunstetter
📖 Goodreads Rating: 4.05/5
Tropes: Small town mystery, secrets, holiday redemption.
In this story, a young woman returns to her small hometown during the holidays to unravel the mystery of her mother’s disappearance years ago. As she digs deeper into her family’s past, she uncovers secrets that could change everything. Though it’s more of a cozy mystery, the tense family dynamics and hidden truths give it a thriller-ish edge.
🎄 Why It’s a Cozy Yet Suspenseful Pick:
This one has that perfect holiday charm, but the mystery at its core keeps you hooked. The small-town setting feels like a warm hug, but the secrets lurking underneath make it a little spooky.
🎁 Personal Take:
I love a good heartwarming read with a touch of tension, and The Christmas Secret fits that perfectly. It was like curling up with a warm blanket but still holding my breath for what was going to happen next.
5. “Silent Night” by Mary Higgins Clark
📖 Goodreads Rating: 3.98/5
Tropes: Suspenseful mystery, family drama, holiday intrigue.
Mary Higgins Clark, queen of suspense, delivers yet another taut thriller, this time set during the holiday season. A young woman is trying to escape a violent past when she’s forced to face a mystery at her family’s remote estate. The chilling setting, combined with Clark’s trademark suspense, makes this a holiday thriller to remember.
🎄 Why It’s Suspenseful:
Clark excels at creating intense atmospheres, and the holiday setting adds to the drama. The pacing is good enough intrigue to keep you turning pages, but never too much that you can guess the ending.
🔍 Personal Take:
I’ve been a fan of Clark’s thrillers for years, and this holiday one did not disappoint. I love how her books always keep me guessing.
6. “Deck the Halls” by Mary and Carol Higgins Clark
📖 Goodreads Rating: 4.03/5
Tropes: Family mystery, holiday cheer with a twist, crime-solving duo.
In Deck the Halls, the mother-daughter crime-solving duo, Alvirah and Willy, take center stage as they try to solve a murder that happens during a festive holiday gathering. The humor, suspense, and holiday fun makes it an engaging read for those who want a little mystery with their Christmas cheer.
🔎 Why It’s Perfect for the Season:
It’s got that perfect combination of holiday warmth and thrilling mystery. The family dynamics make it easy to get invested, and the pacing keeps things exciting throughout.
🎄 Personal Take:
This was such a fun read! It had the right amount of holiday warmth, but the mystery kept me turning pages. Plus, I loved the sleuthing duo—Alvirah and Willy are the right mix of charming and clever.
7. “The Snowman” by Jo Nesbø
📖 Goodreads Rating: 4.17/5
Tropes: Nordic noir, psychological thriller, chilling mystery.
Okay, so this one’s a bit darker, but I had to include it. The Snowman is one of Jo Nesbø’s best-known thrillers, and it has all the elements of a gripping holiday mystery—except it’s got snowmen… who may or may not be linked to a series of grisly murders. It’s eerie, atmospheric, and oh-so-chilling.
❄️ Why It’s a Must-Read for Fans of Dark Thrillers:
The chilling atmosphere of the Norwegian winter is a perfect backdrop for this twisted tale. The pacing is relentless, and Nesbø has a knack for keeping readers on edge until the very end.
💭 Personal Take:
This is the kind of book that sticks with you long after you’ve finished it. It’s dark, suspenseful, and had me completely gripped. Definitely not a light holiday read, but if you love Nordic crime thrillers, this is a holiday read you won’t forget.
8. “Christmas Evil” by Brandon Maggart
📖 Goodreads Rating: 3.85/5
Tropes: Dark comedy, psychological thriller, holiday satire.
Christmas Evil is a dark, satirical thriller that takes a look at the twisted side of the Christmas season. It follows a man who becomes obsessed with Santa Claus and the commercialization of Christmas. As the holiday approaches, his mental state deteriorates in the creepiest possible way. It’s got all the disturbing vibes you never knew you wanted in a Christmas thriller.
🎅 Why It’s Creepy and Brilliant:
John Waters, popular for his bizarre and subversive humor, brings his unique style to this Christmas thriller. It’s disturbing, funny, and unsettling all at once—definitely not your typical holiday fare.
🎄 Personal Take:
This one is a wild ride. It’s definitely not for everyone, but if you like your Christmas with a heavy dose of dark humor and psychological twists, it’s a must-read.
9. “The Christmas Mystery” by Jostein Gaarder
📖 Goodreads Rating: 4.15/5
Tropes: Puzzle, holiday mystery, magical realism.
The Christmas Mystery isn’t a traditional thriller, but it has that sense of intrigue and suspense. It follows Hans Thomas, who, while on a trip with his father, stumbles upon a mysterious advent calendar that leads him through a series of puzzles, each revealing a piece of a larger mystery tied to Christmas. It’s magical, contemplative, and the right level of suspense.
🔮 Why It’s Unique:
This is more of a gentle mystery, but the way it weaves together elements of magic, puzzle-solving, and holiday tradition makes it a thought-provoking holiday read.
🎄 Personal Take:
I loved the combination of mystery and magic in this one. It’s a different kind of thriller, but the suspense builds slowly, and the payoff is incredibly rewarding.
10. The Gift: A Christmas Thriller Novelette by Freida McFadden
📖 Goodreads Rating: 4.1/5
Tropes: Psychological Thriller, Holiday Setting, Suspenseful Mystery.
The Gift is a holiday-themed best-selling psychological thriller that focuses on a seemingly innocent Christmas gift with dark and deadly consequences. The story follows a woman named Anna, who receives a mysterious, anonymous gift on Christmas Eve. At first, it seems like a sweet gesture, but soon the gift unravels into something far more sinister.
As Anna investigates the origins of the gift, she becomes involved in a web of deceit, hidden motives, and a potential threat to her own life. McFadden builds an atmosphere of tension and paranoia that keeps you on the edge of your seat, constantly questioning who can be trusted and what the true intent behind the gift is.
🎁 Why It’s a Good Pick for Christmas Thriller Lovers:
You don’t need to commit to a lengthy novel, but you still get the full psychological tension, twisty plotting, and a satisfying ending. It’s the kind of story that’s easy to devour in one sitting—perfect for a holiday weekend or a quiet evening by the fire.
🎄 Personal Take:
McFadden’s writing is straightforward and suspenseful, and she does a fantastic job of creating tension, even within such a short novella. What I found particularly compelling was how she takes the traditionally joyful season of Christmas and turns it into something sinister. There’s something about receiving a gift that turns out to be dangerous that really taps into universal fears—making the story relatable while still leaving you with that sense of “something’s not right.”
Wrapping It Up
If you’re looking to spice up your holiday season with a touch of suspense, mystery, and maybe a little bit of fear, these thrillers will definitely deliver. Whether you’re into psychological chills, family dramas gone wrong, or twisted holiday tales, there’s something here to satisfy every craving for festive danger. So, cozy up, light that fire, and read these stories that’ll make you look at Christmas a little differently this year. Stay sharp, stay cozy, and may your Christmas be as thrilling as these books! 🔪🎅📚
More Christmas Collections For You:
15 Books To Read At Christmas: Merry Collection 2024
10 Best Christmas Books For Preschoolers
10 Magical Christmas Fantasy Books
10 Young Adult Christmas Books
Table of Contents
